Conisbrough Library Saved? Old News!

Is it true? Has the Mayor really backed down on one of his threats of library closures?

From the South Yorkshire Times:

The immediate future of Conisbrough Library has been secured – after it was taken off a Doncaster Council hit-list of libraries that were set for the axe.

The library was originally one of 14 earmarked for closure across the borough.

But a council spokesman confirmed that Mayor Peter Davies has now taken the facility off the list.

In addition, the council decided last week to use cash reserves to fund the library service for up to a further 12 months – also securing the safety of Denaby Main library for another year.

A consultation is now due to take place to discuss future options for the libraries.

Well, kind of. It is true that Conisbrough library was on the original hit-list, but the proposals were changed at the end of January and replaced Conisbrough and Cantley libraries with Balby and Intake. There are still 14 libraries earmarked for closure:

Armthorpe Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Askern Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Balby Library and Customer Service Centre Under threat
Bawtry Library and Customer Service Centre Under threat
Bentley Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Bessacarr Library Under threat
Cantley Library Safe
Carcroft Library Under threat
Conisbrough Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Denaby Main Library Under threat
Edenthorpe Library Under threat
Edlington Neighbourhood Service Centre and Library Safe
Hatfield Library Safe
Intake Library and Customer Service Centre Under threat
Mexborough Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Moorends Library Under threat
Rossington Library Under threat
Scawthorpe Library Under threat
Sprotbrough Library and Customer Service Centre Under threat
Stainforth Library Under threat
Thorne Library and Customer Service Centre Safe
Tickhill Library Safe
Warmsworth Library Under threat
Wheatley Library Under threat
Woodlands Library and Customer Service Centre Safe

Also of note: the decision to use cash reserves to replace part of this year’s library budget was made before the Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on 18th February. It was announced on the evening of 17th February and published on the council website on the morning of 18th February – considerably more than a week ago as reported by the South Yorkshire Times!

So, what’s this all about? Inaccurate reporting of an out-of-date issue, or something more sinister? Is the Mayor’s office trying to make him look like a kind, library-loving man, when the truth is that he simply spared one library and chose to destroy another? Conisbrough is one of the most deprived areas in Doncaster with far below average educational attainment. These issues weren’t considered when the original list of library closures was announced, and they still haven’t been now. As you can see from the map below, there are many areas in Doncaster in a similar state to Conisbrough.


Why spare one struggling area and not others? As an inquiry into the Wirral’s library closures plan found, we believe that Doncaster council too has failed on the following counts:

  • The Council’s decision to reform its Library Service in the manner proposed places it in breach of its statutory duties;
  • The Council failed to make an assessment of local needs in respect of its Library Services;
  • The Council has not been able to demonstrate that it has had due regard to the general requirements of children;
  • Because the Council did not demonstrate that it had made an adequate assessment of local needs, the Council did not act reasonably in meeting such needs through their proposals;
  • There was an absence of a strategic plan or a development plan for the service;
  • Without adequate plans for outreach services, the Library Service as whole will not be compliant;
  • The evidence submitted to the Inquiry indicates a demonstrable need for a physical presence of a service in some areas for the following reasons:
    • Where libraries are located in an area of significant deprivation
    • Where the Council’s decision on which libraries to close changed
    • Where the Council identified an area of need but subsequently chose to ignore this information
    • Where the Council has failed to meet its own standards in terms of a reasonable distance to travel
    • Where libraries have interdependent links with schools and/or children’s centres
This entry was posted in Update and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Conisbrough Library Saved? Old News!

  1. Chris says:

    This seems like the South Yorkshire Times are reporting old news. It took them a couple of weeks to mention the library closures when they were first announced!

  2. It’s good to see that Conisbrough Library is safe… With the wonder’s of the internet, people are not going out to read books and enjoy the sunshine outside enjoying sports. Instead, people sit and play computer games all day.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s