Where’s Our Consultation?

A Friend of Doncaster Libraries, Charles Thomson, wrote to Mayor Peter Davies voicing his concerns about the threats to the library service. Below is the Mayor’s response:

Dear Mr Thomson

Thank you for your further email.

I cannot decide whether you are joking about the removal of the start and finishing points on Doncaster Racecourse.  Clearly this is impossible.  I repeat that it is vitally important for the success of Doncaster Racecourse that a large number of trees are removed.

I refer now to your concerns regarding the proposed library closures.  An external review of Doncaster’s Library Services, a resulting improvement plan, and a proposed consultation with all stakeholders, was considered by the Council’s Executive Board on 4th August 2010.  The outcome was that a consultation would go ahead with a view to the results being considered in November 2010, with recommendations on the way forward.

This means that any decisions around library closures will be informed by the consultation and review, with usage levels, community need and the condition of the accommodation taken into account.  Library staff, elected members, trade unions, and the general public, have now received a copy of the review, and consultation has started.  The next step will be to start a more specific consultation exercise with the residents of Doncaster, and that is due to start this week.

I trust the above is helpful.


Peter Davies

Mayor Davies is incorrect. As far as Save Doncaster Libraries are aware, the only access that the public have to the review of Doncaster Library and Information Services and the recommendations made by a libraries expert are through the Save Doncaster Libraries blog. It is important to stress that this report was only made available following a Freedom of Information request and has not been made widely available to the public through the council website or public library service. The council are not being transparent, nor are they appropriately involving Doncaster citizens in their decision making processes.

The “specific consultation exercise” to which Mayor Davies alludes may well be this questionnaire (we are not aware of any other consultation), which is hidden in the depths of the council website (which is not heavily used and very inaccessible). Questionnaires were availble for a short time in library branches, but these have now run out. This means that people without access to the internet or who are unable to use computers, who value the library service, are unable to complete the questionnaires.

We are very concerned that this consultation exercise is tokenistic, based on the “decide-announce-defend” model, and that the council has already made its decision to close library branches, reduce opening hours, continue to deprofessionalise the service and reduce its quality even further.

This entry was posted in Update and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Where’s Our Consultation?

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Where’s Our Consultation? « Save Doncaster Libraries -- Topsy.com

  2. Brian Day says:

    Local authorities are required through the Local Government Act 1999 to develop policies which will enable them to deliver an efficient service to a high standard, with Information Technology as a core element, in conjuction with the local community.

    The duty of ‘Best Value’ is the key to success, and is achieved through continuous striving to improve service delivery as a whole in the areas of quality, efficiency and effectiveness. Service users can expect ‘Value for Money’ without added expense, and even, where possible, at reduced cost.

    In order to provide an efficient service, a minimum level of expenditure and investment is required annually.

    The chief executive of the Museums, Libraries and Archives Council, Roy Clare, in 2007, warned that government funding could not be maintained indefinitely at current levels and indicated that additional sources should be sought.

    The need to find new audiences is crucial to ‘Best Value’ reviews, since they are regarded as potentially new patrons, financially, emotionally, and in terms of advocacy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s